“Those who
contemplate the beauty of the earth find reserves of strength that will endure
as long as life lasts. “Rachel Carson, The Sense of Wonder”.
“Those who
contemplate the beauty of the earth find reserves of strength that will endure
as long as life lasts. “Rachel Carson, The Sense of Wonder”.
Ever since the announcement of the 17th Loksabha election schedule by the Election Commission, a googolplex amount of digital data (energy-guzzling medium) has been created, generated, and consumed by the Oceanic amount of space that is finding its place in various social media posts and so also on the What's App group chats.
Dime a dozen amount of forwards - some with heavy images videos and data - are getting circulated in social media and so also are animated discussions that have populated the Whats App groups. Tigers 77 is one such Whats App group, made up of members from the 1977 batch of Sainik School Bijapur students, and yours truly is one of its members. Yesterday, the group was engaged in a highly animated discussion on the forthcoming Lok Sabha election and one of the points discussed was the election manifestos of the parties. During this discussion, an interesting debate unfolded on the election manifestos of BJP and Congress, the two main Political parties. There was a heated debate on social welfare measures/freebies that formed a part of their election manifesto. Those in support of the ruling party justified the election manifesto of the BJP including the promises made in the manifesto. The opponents, however, dubbed the BJP party and their manifesto as a Jhoomla and their leader a dictator. The supporters of Congress tried to justify the promises made by the Congress in their manifesto. There was discussion on the economic ramifications of the election manifestos on the country. Even amidst a heated debate, one common understanding was that in the long term freebies are destined to create problems for the nation and this post of mine is an outcome of our discussion.
In one of my blog posts last year, written on December 13, I had posted about the tragedy of the commons. The concept of the “Tragedy of Commons,” famously elucidated by an ecologist, Garrett Hardin, serves as a poignant warning against the depletion of shared resources due to individual self-interest. Hardin’s thesis posits that when multiple individuals or groups act in their own self-interest without regard for the common good, they inevitably deplete or degrade a shared resource, leading to long-term detrimental consequences for all. Here is a link to that blog.
https://khened.blogspot.com/2023/12/13-december-tragedy-of-commons.html
I am taking this premise forward to address the subject matter in the
context of the 17th Lok Sabha Elections and its impact.
Social welfare mechanisms in an election manifesto typically entail
sustainable policies aimed at uplifting marginalized communities through
education, healthcare, employment opportunities, and social safety nets. These
measures are designed to address systemic inequalities and promote long-term
development. However, there lies a thin line between what social welfare
measures and what one could call freebies.
Freebies often refer to short-term populist measures that provide immediate benefits without addressing underlying issues. While they may garner short-term support, they can strain government finances and undermine economic stability if not carefully managed.
Both NDA and I.N.D.I.A must therefore strike a balance between addressing societal needs through welfare programs and avoiding unsustainable practices that could lead to economic distress. Sustainable policies prioritize investment in human capital and infrastructure while fostering economic growth, ensuring a more equitable and prosperous future for all citizens.
The “Tragedy of Commons” provides a profound understanding of human behavior and its impact on communal resources. This holds critical relevance beyond environmental contexts, extending into the socio-political arena, particularly in the context of our subject matter and electoral politics and practices in India.
India, the world’s largest democracy, is currently in the throes of election fervor, with political parties vying for power through populist measures and promises of freebies. However, amidst the clamor for votes and electoral victories, there lies a perilous path paved with the allure of freebies and short-term gains, ignoring the looming specter of economic ruin and societal degradation akin to the Venezuelan example.
Venezuela once hailed as an economic powerhouse in Latin America, descended into chaos and destitution as successive governments implemented populist policies, including extensive freebie programs. By lavishing free goods and services upon its citizens without sustainable economic foundations, Venezuela unwittingly propelled itself into a downward spiral of hyperinflation, scarcity, and social unrest. The tragic outcome serves as a sobering reminder of the perils of sacrificing long-term economic stability at the altar of short-term political gains.
In the Indian context, the proliferation of freebies, ranging from subsidized food grains and healthcare to loan waivers and cash transfers, has become a cornerstone of electoral strategies. While these promises may garner short-term electoral dividends, their long-term repercussions threaten to undermine the very fabric of the nation’s economic resilience and social cohesion. The Tragedy of Commons, as articulated by Hardin, elucidates the inherent flaw in the culture of freebies perpetuated by political parties. Just as individuals exploiting shared resources lead to their depletion, political parties indulging in reckless populism jeopardize the nation’s fiscal health and social equilibrium.
By pandering to immediate gratification and neglecting the imperative of responsible governance, they squander the collective wealth and well-being of future generations. Moreover, the insidious nature of freebies breeds a culture of dependency and entitlement, eroding the spirit of self-reliance and innovation that are indispensable for national progress. Instead of fostering a culture of empowerment and sustainable development, the proliferation of freebies engenders a vicious cycle of dependency, wherein citizens become passive recipients rather than active participants in the nation’s growth story.
To avert the impending Tragedy of Commons in the realm of Indian politics, a paradigm shift is imperative. Political discourse must transcend the allure of short-term electoral gains and embrace a vision of inclusive growth and responsible governance. Rather than succumbing to the temptation of populist measures, political leaders must chart a course guided by prudence, foresight, and a steadfast commitment to the common good.
In conclusion, the Tragedy of Commons serves as a poignant allegory for the perils of political populism and the unsustainable pursuit of freebies in Indian elections. By heeding the lessons of history, particularly the cautionary tale of Venezuela, and embracing a holistic approach to governance rooted in fiscal discipline and social equity, India can navigate the treacherous waters of electoral politics toward a brighter and more sustainable future for generations to come and look forward to India that is Bharat becoming a developed nation on or before we celebrate our centenary of Indian independence.
This post is courtesy of my fellow Ajeet – An alumnus of Sainik School Bijapur – Ranga, who has been working tirelessly to populate the Ajeet Knowledge Forum (AKF) YouTube Channel with all the videos of the distinguished speakers who were hosted by AKF over the past two and half years. One of our distinguished speakers was Wing Commander Rakesh Sharma, who delivered an inspirational lecture on his tryst with space destiny and motivated young Ajeet and cadet Ajeets, from Sainik School Bijapur who had joined this online lecture.
In response, Sharma uttered words that would reverberate across the nation: "Sare Jaha Se Achha". These words continue to encapsulate the feelings of 1.4 billion people even today. These words became an anthem of pride, echoing through the hearts of millions and inspiring a sense of unity and patriotism.
The alumni of our prestigious Sainik School Bijapur, Ajeets Alumni Association (AAA), had the privilege of hearing firsthand accounts of his journey and experiences in space. It was on 9 April 2022; Rakesh Sharma's enduring legacy was commemorated in a monumental event which was hosted by AKF under the auspices of the AAA.
His lecture transcended the boundaries of time and space, transporting the audience into the awe-inspiring realm of the cosmos. He imparted invaluable insights into the human spirit and the quest for knowledge. His words resonated with the audience, igniting a spark of curiosity and ambition in the hearts of Ajeets and cadet Ajeets.
Here is a link to his talk on the AKF YouTube Channel
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
The AKF - true to the culture and traditions of our alma mater SSBJ - follows a protocol while hosting lectures of distinguished speakers under the auspices of the AKF platform and that includes a six to seven-minute introduction of the speaker by one of the Ajeets. Wing Commander Rakesh Sharma was introduced by one of our senior Ajeets, General Arjun Muthanna. I had the honour to prepare the introduction of the speaker and I am happy to share this on my blog as we celebrate the fortieth year of Wing Commander Rakesh Sharma’s Space Odyssey.
Introduction to Wing Commander Rakesh Sharma for the AKF Meet held on 9th April 2022.
Space has always been fantasised about and romanticised by humankind. There
are very few people who have had the pleasure and privilege to have fulfilled
their fantasy of going to space. We the Ajeets are so very lucky that today’s speaker
- Wing Commander Rakesh Sharma- is the one and only person from India to have
achieved this distinction. Having walked the very precincts of the institute,
from where Rakesh Sharma ji passed out – National Defence Academy Pune – on
behalf of the AAA and AKF, it is a great honour for me to introduce Wing
Commander Rakesh Sharma and I am so very humbled to be doing this honour.
Wing Commander Rakesh
Sharma is a name that no Indian will ever forget. His iconic “Saare Jahah Se
Accha” reply to the question that Mrs Indira Gandhi, the then Prime Minister of
India, asked, “Bharat Asman Se Kaisa Dikhta Hai? (how India looked from outer
space) is something which resonates with all Indians. For all Indians, his words
have remained as profound as the words of Neil Armstrong – “One small step for man and a giant leap for
mankind”. Rakesh Sharma continues to be
the first and the only Indian to date and the 138th person to
travel in space. He spent eight days in the Salyut 7 space station beginning on
3 April 1984 and his feat made India the 14th nation to send a man to outer
space.
Rakesh Sharma ji is the recipient of the prestigious Ashoka Chakra, the highest peacetime gallantry award, awarded by the Indian Government. His other coveted awards include the Hero of the Soviet Union and The Order of Lenin by the erstwhile Soviet Government.
Born on 13 January 1949 in Patiala Punjab - on the auspicious Lohri (Sankranti) Day festival, the boy Rakesh Sharma was destined for an extraordinary achievement later in his life. He remains the only Indian citizen to have travelled into space to date. (There have been other Indian-origin astronauts, but they were not bonafide Indian citizens at the time of space travel). Rakesh Sharma completed his schooling in Hyderabad at St. George's Grammar School and graduated from Nizam College, Hyderabad. He then joined the prestigious National Defence Academy as an Air Force plebe in July 1966 and was commissioned into the Indian Air Force as a pilot in 1970.
Indian tryst with space had begun in the late sixties with the dreams of
Vikram Sarabhai and Prof Satish Dhawan. By the 1980s, the Indian Space Research
Organisation was on a development curve so impressive that on certain space
missions, the Russian Space Agency collaborated with ISRO. In one such
collaboration – space mission - Squadron Leader Rakesh Sharma was selected for
a space voyage, on 20 September 1982, to become a cosmonaut and go into space
as part of a joint programme between the Indian Air Force and the Soviet
Interkosmos space programme on the Soyuz T-11 with Russian cosmonauts. That
meant the standby Indian Astronaut Wing Commander Ravish Malhotra had to stay
back.
Sharma left for Russia to complete a gruelling training under the
Russian scientists' watch. Unfortunately, when he was undergoing his training,
tragedy struck his family but then like that quintessential brave Indian soldier
that he was, he continued on the mission entrusted to him, and on 3 April 1984,
he was launched into space as on schedule thus becoming the first Indian to go
to space.
The Soyuz T-11 spacecraft carrying cosmonauts including Sharma docked
and transferred the three-member Soviet-Indian international crew, consisting
of the ship's commander, Yury Malyshev, and flight engineer, Gennadi Strekalov,
to the Salyut 7 Orbital Station. Sharma spent 7 days, 21 hours, and 40 minutes
aboard the Salyut 7 during which his team conducted scientific and technical
studies which included forty-three experimental sessions. Interestingly
Rakesh Sharma had the privilege to savour Indian delicacies in space courtesy of
the Defence Food Research Laboratory in Mysore. It had packed Indian delicacies
viz. suji halwa, alu choley , and vegetable pulao for Sharma,
which he gladly shared with Malyshev and Strekalov in outer space. Yoga which
has now gained international fame is what Rakesh Sharma practised for 10
minutes every day while in space and advised other astronauts to do the same to
avert space sickness.
Rakesh Sharma flew 21 Operational Missions on a Mig-21 aircraft during the Indo-Pak
War in 1971. He was selected for the Production Test Pilots Course in 1975 and
later, in 1979 for the Experimental Test Pilots Course at the Test Pilot’s
School of the Indian Air Force’s Aircraft and Systems Testing Establishment,
Bangalore.
He served as an Air Force Test Pilot for 15 years before being seconded to the Industry, in 1987. It was during this period that he was selected for the Joint Indo-Soviet Space Mission.
Rakesh Sharma returned
to his test flying career after the space flight and served as the Chief
Project Pilot of India’s Light Combat Aircraft ‘Tejas’ and, as Chief Test Pilot
of Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. (HAL). During this period, his skills were
extensively utilized by HAL on its indigenous Intermediate Jet Trainer Project.
Out of a flying career spanning 33 years, he spent 24 years testing aircraft
and systems. During this period, he flew 4000 hrs on all front-line fighter
aircraft of the Indian Air Force, apart from the NT-33, NF-16, and the F-18.
Retired from test flying in July 2001.
Post his retirement he joined the IT Industry in 2001 as the Chief Operating Officer of a Business Process Management IT company. Later, he headed the Indian Aerospace and Defence business unit of Parametric Technology Corporation, USA, till his retirement from active service in 2009.
Post-retirement, he was appointed as Chairman of the Board of Candela Labs, an IT company located in Bangalore till he decided to step down in 2019.
He now
lives in Coonoor in Tamil Nadu and is a non-executive chairman of Bangalore
(Bengaluru) Based Cadila Lab.
Incidentally, yours truly had the honour to host Wing Commander Rakesh Sharma as one of the distinguished guests while commemorating the 60th year of human space flight in April 2021. It was on 12th April 1961 that Yuri Gagarin became the first Cosmonaut in Space. To commemorate this historic occasion, the Nehru Science Centre, Mumbai tied up with the Russian Centre for Science and Culture to organise a mega event involving Cosmonauts from Russia and Wing Commander Rakesh Sharma. This event was organised on 9 April 2021, online.
Ten years ago, on 18 December 2014, an interesting art exhibition entitled “Deconstructed Innings: A Tribute to Sachin Tendulkar” was open...