Wednesday, 6 May 2020

Rabindranath Tagore : A Tribute to the Polymath on his Jayanthi.











Today, the 7th May, 2020, besides being Budha Poornima - the birth day of Bhagwan Gautam Buddha -  also happens to be the birth anniversary of one of the greatest sons of India - Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore, the first non European and also the first nonwhite to be conferred with the coveted Nobel Prize in Literature (1913). Rabindranath Tagore was a creative genius and a polymath; a versatile poet, a par excellence short story writer, novelist, playwright, essayist, artist, rationalist, as well as a talented painter, whose pictures with their mixture of representation and abstraction began to manifest late into his career. Rabindranath Tagore (Thakur) was born on 7th May, 1861, in a very rich Brahmin family to Debendranath Tagore and Sarada Devi in the famous Jorasanko mansion, the ancestral home of the Tagore family in Kolkata (Calcutta). He was the youngest sibling in his family. Tagore holds a unique distinction that two of his poems have been befittingly chosen as the national anthems of India and Bangladesh - “Jana Gana Mana” & “Amar Sonar Bangla” respectively, which is an extraordinary achievement that any poet can ever aspire for. Tagore used colloquial language, deviating from well established Sanskrit influenced Bengali, to reshape Bengali literature and music by introducing new prose and verse forms that could connect easily with the masses. The polymath Tagore’s contributions in the field of art, literature, playwright etc are well known all across the country and so also internationally but his extraordinary painting skills, which he acquired at the age of 67, are not much known beyond the boundaries of Bengal.

Therefore, when an opportunity came calling to commemorate Rabindranath Tagore’s sesquicentennial year of birth, the Ministry of Culture, Government of India, commissioned a monumental paintings exhibition: “The Last Harvest : Paintings of Rabindranath Tagore”, which was curated by Prof R Sivakumar, Shantiniketan with his insightful thoughts and understanding of the Poet painter - Tagore. This exhibition, of the original paintings of Tagore, was organised in nine major museums across three continents and on its return to India, it was presented in all the three National Galleries of Modern Art in New Delhi, Mumbai and Bangalore and so also in Bhopal and Hyderabad. I was privileged to be the Director of NGMA, Mumbai when this exhibition travelled to Mumbai during the period from April to June 2013. The exhibition was a treat for the art connoisseurs of the city of Mumbai and all through the exhibition period a series of outreach programs and activities were organised to connect Tagore and his creative endeavours with the people of Mumbai, courtesy Godrej Culture Lab and various other art and culture organisations in Mumbai, which made the exhibition all the more special.

Tagore lived a creative life for eight decades until his passing away at the age of 80 plus years, on 7th August, 1941 at his ancestral home in Calcutta (now Kolkata). His mortal remains may have been confined to the holy fire in the ritualistic Hindu cremation traditions and the fire may have consumed his physical body, but then he has left behind - for the world and India - a legacy and heritage that will remain etched in golden letters in the annals of history, which no fire or any other force can obliterate. He lived an extraordinary creative life, beginning his last aspects of creations - the paintings -  in his late sixties. Tagore has left behind a rich heritage of words, music, poetry, paintings, ideas and ideals and his legacy continues to have that power to move us even today and for eternity. On learning about Tagore’s death, Nehru, who was in Jail, wrote;  “Gandhi and Tagore, two types entirely different from each other, and yet both of them typical of India, both in the long line of India’s great men … It is not so much because of any single virtue but because of the tout ensemble, that I felt that among the world’s great men today Gandhi and Tagore were supreme as human beings”.

Tagore is a national figure in India, whose stature comes very close to the Mahatma - the title given by Tagore, to the father of our nation, Mahatma Gandhi. Gandhi ji, for generations to come, will continue to be revered and considered as an embodiment of our country’s freedom struggle and for very strongly providing that extraordinary leadership for political action. Tagore on the other hand being a creative poet, playwright, novelist, musician, theorist, educationist and painter, all rolled into one, personified the cultural ethos of India with roots in an age-old heritage of this great nation of ours. Even today, and for eons to come, one cannot think of Bengali culture without Tagore being central to it. Tagore’s name and fame and his contributions to the field of literature, art and culture spread across the world. French Nobelist, Romain Rolland (1915, Literature), was fascinated both by Gandhi and Tagore. On completion of his book on Gandhi he wrote to one of the Indian academic ‘ I have finished my book on Gandhi, in which I pay tribute to your two great river-like souls, overflowing with the divine spirit - Tagore and Gandhi’. Tagore greatly admired Gandhi but he had many disagreements with him on a variety of subjects, particularly on the role of rationality and of science, and the nature of economic and social development. Tagore always encouraged room for reasoning, and for a less traditionalist view, and more respect for science and for objectivity, generally.

The clash between Gandhi and Tagore, on their poles apart attitude towards science and rationality, is evidenced in their outlook towards a tragic natural disaster, which struck India in 1934. Bihar was struck by a devastating earthquake in January 1934 and it killed thousands of people. During this period Gandhi ji had immersed himself in the fight against the age old Indian traditions of untouchability, which was plaguing our country. Unfortunately, when the earthquake tragedy struck Bihar, Gandhi ji, in an unscientific and irrational manner, connected this natural disaster with the purported sins of practising untouchability by Indians and that the earthquake was a divine chastisement sent by God for our sins of untouchability. He said “for me there is a vital connection between the Bihar calamity and the untouchability campaign.” Rabindranath Tagore was also a great advocate of equality who too abhorred the irrational practise of untouchability and had joined hands with Gandhi in the movements against it. However, Tagore protested against Gandhi ji on his irrational interpretation of a natural calamity as a sin that was responsible for the suffering and death of so many innocent people, including children. He outrightly rejected Gandhi ji’s unscientific linkage of earthquake with human ethical failures. 

Down south there was another legendary engineer, Sir M Visvesvaraya, who was about the age of Tagore and his ideas on rationality and science and technology resembled Tagore. Sir MV had similar differences with Gandhi ji as that of Tagore on subjects like rationality, science and technology and so also on the concept and notion of economic development of the country. The irony is that there is not much that could find from archive on the personal connection between Sir MV and Tagore. However, in the year 1928 records suggest that Tagore stayed for three weeks in Bangalore, at the majestic colonial era building Balabrooie, on Palace Road. It was during his three weeks recuperating stay that Tagore wrote his famed Shesher Kobita and also some part of Yogayog. This building, which is a treasure trove of stories from Bengaluru's colonial past, was once home to its builder, Lord Mark Cubbon, Sir M. Visvesvaraiah and other illustrious stalwarts. It was also the residence of former Chief Ministers S.Nijalingappa and D. Devaraj Urs. Unfortunately over time this building has come to be known as a haunted place since the politicians (Chief Ministers) irrationally fear to stay in this building, strongly believing that it is haunted and anyone who stays in the building would quickly lose power. Sir MV who was just about a year senior to Tagore, loved reading Tagore and one of his favourite book was ‘Stray Birds’,  which was penned by Tagore. It provides a connect between nature, man and his environment as seen by a person sitting by a window where stray birds are seen singing and flying. The book also contained one-line poems, which are often just an image or the distillation of a thought, which stays with the reader in his mind and does not fly away as easily as the birds. Tagore was knighted in 1915, but gave up his knighthood after the massacre of demonstrators at the infamous Jallianwala bagh, in 1919. By then Tagore was beginning to be acclaimed globally. 

Tagore’s global recognition is evidenced in a book “The Golden Book of Tagore”, which was published as homage to Tagore, from India and the world, on the occasion of Tagore’s 70th birth anniversary, in 1930. This book is a testimony to the love and reverence that the intellectuals of the world bore for Tagore. The book has been sponsored by the leading intellectuals of the world such as Gandhi, Albert Einstein, and Kostes Palamas, and was brought out on the suggestion of French writer Romain Rolland. The book indicates how highly regarded Tagore was in India and around the world. The great Albert Einstein, who was one of the sponsors of the book, met Rabindranath Tagore in the same year in Berlin on July 14, 1930. This historic meeting between the two hogged the headlines ‘as the coming together of science and spirituality’. It was hailed as one of the most intellectually stimulating conversations in the annals of history. Their conversation, which mostly centred around science and the age old Indian traditions of spirituality has been chronicled in a book ; ‘Science and the Indian Tradition: When Einstein Met Tagore”  by David L. Gosling. 

Helen Keller, an American political activist and a deaf and blind author known around the world as a symbol of courage in the face of overwhelming odds, had this to say about Tagore ; “ Sitting beside Rabindranath Tagore and sharing his thoughts is like spending one's days beside the Sacred River, drinking deep of honeyed wisdom.” Tagore’s global recognition is also evidenced in the statements of several other international thinkers, writers and intellectuals. Russian author, Ms. Anna Akhmatova, who received the highest nominations for the Nobel Prize in Literature, was also one of Tagore’s admirers and she translated his poems into Russian in the mid-1960s. She says “that mighty flow of poetry, which takes its strength from Hinduism as from the Ganges, and is called Rabindranath Tagore.” 

Tagore also had his influence on other thinkers of the world. His typical physical appearance – intellectual looking, handsome, bearded, dressed in non-Western clothes – to some extent may have helped him in being seen as a carrier of exotic wisdom. Yasunari Kawabata, first Japanese Nobel Laureate in Literature, 1968, treasured memories from his middle-school days of “this sage-like poet” - Tagore - and he goes on to add; ‘His white hair flowed softly down both sides of his forehead; the tufts of hair under the temples also were long like two beards, and linking up with the hair on his cheeks, continued into his beard, so that he gave an impression, to the boy I was then, of some ancient Oriental wizard’.

One of the greatest and an emotionally touching tribute to Tagore’s poetry comes from a World War I martyr, Wilfred Owen, who wrote some of the best British poetry on World War I. In November 1918 Wilfred was killed in action at an young age of 25, just one week before the Armistice. Susan Owen, the mother of Wilfred Owen, wrote a letter to Rabindranath Tagore in 1920, describing her last conversations, which she had with her son before her son left for the war, which would most unfortunately take his life. Susan wrote that her son said goodbye with those wonderful words of yours ‘When I go from hence, let this be my parting word”.  Among the remains of Wilfred, which were returned from the battle field to his mother, was a pocket notebook. She wrote to Tagore that her son’s pocket notebook contained  the writings of Tagore with his name written beneath those words”. This was a touching recognition and emotional tribute that Tagore had received from a very young World War I martyr, who himself was an outstanding poet. 

Tagore wrote most of his essays and poetry at the Shantiniketan (Abode of Peace), a small town, which grew around the school that Tagore had founded in Bengal in 1901. Tagore not only conceived an imaginative and innovative system of education at the Shantiniketan, but through his writings and his influence on students and teachers, he was able to use the school as a very strong base from which he could take a major part in India’s social, political, and cultural movements. Most of his essays covered subjects ranging from literature, politics, culture, social change, religious beliefs, philosophical analysis, international relations, and much else. Coincidentally the Cambridge University Press published Tagore’s ideas and reflections to the fore, which coincided with the fiftieth anniversary of Indian independence (1997). This publication helped in examining what kind of leadership in thought and understanding, Tagore provided to his fellow citizens in the Indian subcontinent, in the first half of 20th century. 

Tagore’s recognition, particularly as a poet and also as a dramatist, essayist, short story writer, musician, humanist, philosopher and educationist, has been very well documented both nationally and internationally. However his paintings have not had the same impact as his other creative facets, especially among the common Indians and therefore the sesquicentennial exhibition of paintings of Tagore, which was organised at NGMA  Mumbai helped in creating awareness about the creativity of Tagore in paintings, which are now preserved as national treasures.

Tagore at the age of 67, to use his own words, "fell under the enchantment of lines" when he discovered that his hand was moving automatically across the pages of his manuscripts transforming the scratches and erasures into designs. For the next 12 years of his life he harnessed his new found love for painting and produced nearly 2,000 paintings. Although he used all kinds of paints and produced coloured chalk drawings, pastels, and later dry-points and etchings, Tagore's preferred medium was liquid colour. He often used ordinary fountain-pen ink and when this was not available; he crushed flower petals and used them as pigments. He rarely used a brush, instead he worked with a cloth soaked in colour, the back of a fountain-pen, his thumb, a stick or, more often, a knife. His original paintings, which are now declared as a National Treasure, from different collectors and sources, primarily from  the collections of Shantiniketan and NGMA Delhi, were used in the Last Harvest exhibition and these paintings illustrated that Tagore's art was peculiarly his own. 

Tagore, although took to painting very late into his career, did manage to organise some international exhibitions of his paintings, the first of which was held in 1930 in Paris. The same year a few of his  paintings were also shown in London, Berlin and New York. His first exhibition in India was organised in February, 1932 when 265 of his drawings, paintings and engravings were displayed to the public in Calcutta. A year after that (1933) Tagore held another exhibition in Bombay. In 1946, four of his paintings were included in an international exhibition of modern art organised by UNESCO in Paris. The UNESCO also featured an illustrated article on his works which figured in the issue of The UNESCO Courier, "Famous Authors as Artists", in August 1957.

Tagore said “My pictures are my versification in lines if by chance they are entitled to claim recognition, it must be primarily for some rhythmic significance of form which is ultimate, and not for any interpretation of an idea, or representation of a fact”. For him “painting was the language of the universe and that the world of sound is a tiny bubble in the silence of the infinite”. He further elucidates his love for painting by stating; “the Universe has its only language of gesture; it talks in the voice of pictures and dance”. He continues ‘every  object in this world proclaims in the dumb signal of lines and colors the fact that it is not a mere logical abstraction or a mere thing of use, but is unique in itself carries the miracle of its existence’.  In a picture the artist creates the language of undoubted reality, which every human being can see and interpret in his/her own ways, irrespective of the language, cast, creed, social structure that each one belongs to. For Tagore a piece of art has its own inner artistic significance.

Tagore, while speaking about his paintings, once said “People often ask me about the meaning of my pictures. I remain silent even as my pictures are. It is for them to express and not to explain. They have nothing ulterior behind their own appearance for the thoughts to explore and words to describe and if that appearance carries its ultimate worth then they remain, otherwise they are rejected and forgotten even though they may have some scientific truth or ethical justification”.

His concepts of education even today has great relevance and his dream for empowering the rural India continues to remain a challenge for all of us today. Tagore held that education must allow the child to develop in the context of nature. He believed that “the sweep of the earth and the expanse of the sky, the quietness of the evening and the promise of the morning, the beauty of the stars and the radiance of the sun must permeate the personality of the child”. From his own experience Tagore learnt that education divorced from social life and cultural traditions, and, more important still, bereft of contacts with nature became for the child an imposition and a burden. These very facts are effectively used by the science centres in creating interest in science among the students. 

For Tagore, art had its place along with mathematics and science. He believed, and he earnestly tried to carry out his beliefs in his school, that all aspects of the child's personality must develop harmoniously. He was one of the earliest among modern educational thinkers to emphasize activity as an essential principle of education. Education, for Tagore, was the foundation of society; that the teachers of today are the arbiters of the destiny of society of tomorrow and the day after.

Tagore worked tirelessly to empower his people in the villages. He believed that able men will stay in villages only when village life is reconstructed to provide educational facilities, health services, improved communications and adequate and wholesome water supply. Able men and women will stay in the villages only if there are opportunities for the fullest development of their personality. What a prophetic vision it has turned out to be. The current Covid pandemic played out the dying need in India for implementing the vision of Tagore for the development of villages. Had this got the attention of government post the independence, perhaps the pain and anguish that we are now witnessing on the faces of the stranded labours in most metropolitan cities during the current lockdown due to the Covid Pandemic would have been largely reduced. Hopefully the lessons that we have learnt during the Covid pandemic will make policy makers to rethink on the prophetic vision of Tagore and aim to develop our villages and help in creating job opportunities for our village brethren.

There can never be an end when one starts writing about Tagore, and therefore I am ending this tribute to Tagore by wishing that May he continue to inspire us, from the heavenly abode that is now home to him.

Jai Hind. Jaya he Jaya he Jaya Jaya Jaya Jaya he.

14 comments:

Manash said...

Tagore is known to be almost a project to himself. Whenever some feeling, idea, thought or concept touched his mind, he immediately immortalized it with some form of expression - song, poem, story, essay, painting, drama, political activism, rural development, banking, architecture (created new low-cost designs of houses and many household items like boxes, chairs etc.), science (he authored a wonderful book of science dedicated to Prof. S N Bose that till date is considered on of the best science book ever written in Bengali, he created Bengali terminologies for studying science in Bengali with painstaking effort) and even he tried his hands in film making (did shot Natir Puja as Director) or education (starting a school and then making an a university out of it. But he he himself thought that music was his most creative endeavor - he said once that even if everything I did perishes, the music I composed (both lyrics, tunes and yes, many new rhythms) will still persist. Your article reflects this project attitude of his to bear an eternal urge to ceaselessly create and create and create without caring for the limitations of training, skill, form or resources even. You have rightly pointed out his affinity to rationality. In fact, he believed that every person should have a philosophical benchmark against which all data, history and actions are to be validated. To him this litmus of life was science and rationality. His interest in science and rationality was not just cursory. He was a regular avid reader of science text books which often used to import. Scientific American was a regular read for him. His late found love in painting was probably a quick way of expressing and recording his feelings. Interestingly, he was a very traditional writer in a sense that he used to impose strong censorship on himself about what is to be written and what cannot be written, often he used some strong word and then penned it through (making a design sometimes) to replace it with a softer word. But in his painting he was uninhibited. Sometimes he used to paint even two or three pieces a day. Sometimes the papers got torn up by fast movements of his restless painting tools. This shows he was a man in hurry when he used to paint, which he never was as a writer. You have nicely captured many of these characteristics - but a major miss is the mention of his song and music which he considered to be very important in his creative spree. It is not easy to paint a pen-picture of comprehensive Tagore in one article. For example it is very difficult to portray in short span why he never believed in so-called nationalism and even opposed the Swadeshi movement. he believed more in international humanism than a straight axiom that just because it is my country, it is the best of the world. For him the country was its people beyond anything. His treatment of nature, his aphrodisiac, or death as a part of life - all merit separate articles. Your attempt itself to construct an all-in-one essay was ambitious and you have produced a fairly justified one for those who knows him a little but would like to know him more fully. Thank you sir. It can do a world of good to Indians if they really care to know him and preserve his legacy.

Unknown said...

Superb Blog, covered most of Tagores work..came to new things about Tagores life...

Unknown said...

A very well written blog on Rabindra Nath. Actually Tagore had created a cult of its' own and a majority of Bengali community feel pride in thinking himself belonging to that cult. There are people who think about Tagore in every walk of his life. In our child hood days, we were introduced to Tagore's cult through our family education system. In fact Tagore had to great extent framed the social and cultural framework of Bengali community during pre and post independance era. It may appear something queer. But Tagore cult still now plays an major role in the psych of two Bengals. The two sides are separated on the basis of religion. But till date Tagore cult plays the underlying unifying factor between two Bengals defying the strict religious ruling.
Very recently I was listening a live debate on different aspects of Tagore conducted by five famous literarry stalwarts pundits of Bangladesh telecast from Bangladesh TV.
They were claiming with great pride that study of Tagore and his works is carried out more vigorously by Bangladesh rather than West Bengal.
Next time I shall be delighted to hear from you about Tagore on this aspect also.
While speaking about Tagore's painting, some light could have been thrown upon Abanindra Nath Thakur, his own brother's son. That definitely would not have been out of place.
Thank you Mr Khened for your this outstanding blog.
Thank you.

Unknown said...

Previous remark is from Subrata Sen.

Unknown said...

Another aspect of Tagore we often overlook is the cultural base of Shantiniketan an organisation created by him. So far there are three such organisations which have been developed having its root within the cultural ethoes and values of India. They are Ramakrishna Mission established by Swami Vivekananda, Pondicherry Ashram by Rishi Aurovindo, Shantiniketan our modern India by Mahatma Gandhi. Although it is debatable that how much we follow Gandhian philosophy. The same is true for today's Shantiniketan as well.
--- Subrata Sen

Unknown said...

It was wrongly stated ,three organisations. It would be four organisations.

Anonymous said...

qqq

Anonymous said...

When the ignoramus shows off as erudite, The ignorance shows. The third and the fifth comments are glaring examples. Juvenile mistakes in grammar and poor sense of ideas are apparent.Calling Tagore philosophy a cult is horrible. '...an major role...', '....had to great extent framed...' are laughable. It shows the lack of judgement, poor knowledge of the subject and the language. The fifth comment is a fundamentalist and dogmatic reflection that Tagore abhorred all his life. Tagore never believed in the so called Indian Values of Culture which is a recent political coinage. He ever talked of an international outlook. How can one make such irresponsible comment that Shantiniketan was based on Indian values when Tagore himself in 1921 did choose the motto of the university (in 1921 it was converted from a school to a university) - Yatra visvam bhavatyekanidam (where the whole world can find a nest)!!! The Indian Value call every other person an outsider, invader, intruder. Shantiniketan was an abode of learning with international vision and not anything colored in saffron to call it stupidly as based on Indian values. Other organizations mentioned in the comment are of different objective and history. The comment shows the person's absolute poor sense of historical interpretation. And considering the so called Indian Values, there are thousands of organizations that are similar as Ramakrishna Mission or the Arvinda Ashram, some of them are even bigger. Tens of Gauriya Maths, Bharat Sebashram Sangh, RSS all claim that and Tagore neither claimed it, nor did he believe in it. Khened sir, you may better keep such ill-informed statements away from your blog. They demean your spirit and class.

INDRANIL SANYAL said...

This is a very well written article and except a few, there is not many factual errors, the most prominent being that Tagore wrote mostly at Shantiniketan. The fact is that Tagore penned most of his early writings while staying in three zamindary estates of Tagore family in eastern Bengal, namely Shilaidah, Patisar and Shazadpur. Later on, when the family property was apportioned, Tagore lost the control of these estates and finally shifted to Shantiniketan.

The most glaring omission in the article is Tagore's views on contemporary socio-political developments, without which no writing on Tagore can be complete. One must understand that Tagore was not only a creative genius, but also the intellectual leader of India (along with Gandhi). In the time of crisis, common people and politicians alike, turned to Tagore for his guidance. We can see that on numerous occasions, Gandhi, Nehru and Subhash Bose sought Tagore's opinions on various national issues. Below, I am giving my understanding of Tagore's views on socio-political issues, on nationalism and on the question of Hindu-Muslim problem:

Tagore & Nationalism:

Nobody can accuse Tagore of being unpatriotic or anti-national; nevertheless, his views significantly differed from those of other nationalist politicians. Tagore was at the forefront of anti-Bengal Partition, Boycott and Swadeshi movement that started in Bengal in 1905. But as it turned violent (through what we called at that time as Revolutionary Terrorism) and anti-Muslim, Tagore realized the futility of the movement, as it alienated common people and became a terrorist activity led by Anushilan Samity and Jugantar Dal, and distanced himself from the movement. He also felt that Swadeshi movement was bound to fail because it would be impossible to convince common people to buy commodities which are of inferior quality and yet expensive. Later on, he examined the inherent defects of such ultra-nationalistic movements in his famous novel Ghare-baire, which was filmed by Satyajit Ray in 1982.

During the first world war, Tagore noticed how Japan, in the name of nationalism, unleashed a reign of terror in China and Korea. Same was done by Germany in Europe. Tagore protested and distinguished between patriotism and nationalism. He could correctly detect nationalism as a disguise for imperialism. In 1917, his book titled Nationalism was published by McGraw-Hill from New York. The book contained four essays, namely Nationalism in the West, Nationalism in Japan, Nationalism in India and The Last Sunset of the Century. Here, Tagore vehemently criticized the imperialism and exposed its true nature. As a result, Tagore lost popularity in Japan and the USA but was highly appreciated by European intellectuals like Romain Roland, Sylvan Levi and others.

To be continued......

INDRANIL SANYAL said...

From the previous.....

Tagore's anti-imperialist stand was well known globally as Tagore was very vocal against European (and Japanese) imperialism in Asia and Africa. Through his famous poem titled Africa, he called for solidarity with the black people of Africa in their struggle against imperialism. In 1929, when Tagore visited Japan for the fourth time, a few Korean students of Tokyo ( Korea was a colony of Japan at that time) invited him to visit Korea. Tagore expressed his inability due to lack of time, but wrote a four-liner for them:

In the Golden days of Asia
Korea was its lamp-bearer;
The lamp is waiting to be lighted again
For the illumination of the East.

What a prophetic poem! The poem was translated into Korean by the famous Korean poet Chu-yu-Haan and was published in the East Asia Daily in April 1929.

Tagore was no-doubt a liberal humanist and he noticed the breach of humanism both in Nazi Germany and Stalin's Russia, as he visited the countries on number of occasions. In one of his essays he termed Nazism and Bolshevism two sides of the same coin.

Back home, we know that Tagore was the first to protest against Jalianwallabagh massacre and returned the knighthood. Prof Abul Fazl, a prominent intellectual from Bangladesh and a close associate of Tagore from 1930 or before, told us another story. Shortly after the massacre, Tagore was travelling to Europe via Bombay port. Meanwhile, the National Congress was virtually silent on the massacre, nor did they congratulate Tagore for his denouncing of knighthood. The only protest meeting organized on behalf of Congress was by Jinnah ( then in Congress) in Bombay. As Jinnah came to know that Tagore was in Bombay, he invited Tagore to the meeting. Tagore had no time, but he sent a message to the meeting, which was read out by Jinnah.

Tagore's essays with criticism of the British rule in India was limited, and it created confusion among his admirers. To dispel this, just before his death, Tagore wrote one of the best essays of his life titled Sabhyataar Sangkat (Crisis of the Civilization), in which he emphatically predicted that the days of British imperialism in India was limited. In six years from his death, British left the subcontinent.

To be continued.....

INDRANIL SANYAL said...

Tagore & the Muslims:

There were many secular leaders in India among the nationalists like Nehru and even some historians prefer to call Jinnah as secular, but Tagore was perhaps the only national figure (and may be Subhash Bose too) who was trusted by Hindus and Muslims alike. There was no doubt about Tagore's secular credentials, and throughout his life, Tagore tried to forge Hindu-Muslim unity in Bengal.

In 1905, during the Banga-Bhanga (Partition of Bengal) movement, a large numbers of poor Muslims of East Bengal supported the partition. To silence them, the agitators, supported by some zamindars of East Bengal, started setting fire on the houses and farms of poor Muslims. Tagore protested vehemently and could foresee the failure of the movement as it alienated the majority population (Muslims). Tagore wrote patriotic poems ( Banglar Mati, Banglar jal....) and called for Hindu-Muslim unity (Bangaleer ghare joto bhai-bon....). He tried to repair the damage done by Vivekananda and Bankimchandra by equating Indian Nationalism with Hindu Nationalism. Tagore was only partly successful.

In 1920s and 30s, Tagore extensively toured eastern Bengal and came across many Muslim intellectuals. They exchanged ideas and Muslims found in him an ideal icon of Bengali nationalism and Hindu-Muslim unity. Muslim elites started sending their children to Shantiniketan ( for example, Syed Mujtaba Ali, the famous writer, graduated from Shantiniketan in 1920s). Tagore's affectionate mentoring to Bengal's rebel poet Kazi Nazrul Islam is well known, despite their differences of opinion on many issues. A K Fazlul Haq, the first Prime Minister of Bengal, was a great admirer of Tagore and sought his blessings while he took oath as the leader of the Muslim League-Krishak Praja Party Govt in Bengal in 1937.

Tagore was the first to highlight the syncretic Sufism through the poems of Muslim ascetics. His lectures on Lalan Shah and Hason Raja at Oxford in 1931 drew the global attention towards the secular, syncretic culture of medieval Bengal. During his visit to Iran, he recalled the paramount influence of Persia on all oriental cultures.

Tagore was also very sensitive about the feelings of Muslims in India. When in 1937, Nehru, as the Congress President, sought his opinion on whether Vande Mataram could be India's national anthem, Tagore replied in negative as it contained some lines which might hurt the Muslims. Tagore refrained from writing any story with the plot of a Muslim family , because, as he later explained to journalist Bande Ali Mian, he feared that his ignorance of the nitty-gritty of Muslim way of life could lead him to depict something wrongly!

After 1947, when the Language movement intensified in East Pakistan, the Muslims in Bengal found in Tagore a rallying point against Punjabi/Urdu domination in Bengal. In 1961, Khwaja Sahabuddin, former Nawab of Dhaka and Information & Broadcasting Minister of Ayyub Khan Govt. banned playing Rabindra Sangit in Radio and TV because, the Govt, felt that " Tagore is not a part of Pakistani culture". The intellectuals protested and 18 prominent intellectuals of Dhaka signed a declaration which stated that they believe that Tagore is a part of their culture and they would play Tagore song. No doubt that independent Bangladesh adopted a Tagore song as their national anthem. Tagore is much more widely and seriously studied in Bangladesh than he is in West Bengal!

Hay Kobi, Laha Pranaam.

Erin said...

Writing essays, letters and stories increases the learning abilities of students. Tha’s why writing is much necessary in schools and colleges. Students should not feel burden writing work and must feel that i’s not something which they can’t do. It can be done with little pain. Try this WritePaper.Info.

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing this...Please visit our art gallery: Art Gallery in Kolkata!

Anonymous said...

Great post!!.

Contemporary Indian Art

Indian Modern Art Paintings

TMM 2025 Fund Raising Target : Recollections of a Nostalgic Memory.

  This post is courtesy of an Instagram post by the United Way Mumbai under the caption “Meet our Change Runners and Young Leaders” for the ...