Skip to main content

MADAM’ Moment in Nobel Prize in Chemistry for the Year 2020

 MADAM’ Moment in Nobel Prize in Chemistry for the Year 2020

The Nobel Prize in chemistry, 2020 was announced yesterday and it has been  awarded to ‘Madam’ scientists Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier for their pioneering work on the development of CRISPR tool for gene editing, a discovery that holds out the possibility of curing genetic diseases. This years Nobel Prize in Chemistry is an extraordinary moment for the global scientific community since it is a rarity that Nobel Prizes are awarded exclusively for lady scientists. This historic ‘Madam’ moment is significant considering the fact that the Nobel club is majorly populated by gentlemen scientists, particularly in the field of sciences and that there  are only seven scientists including Marie Curie - winner of two Nobel Prizes, and her daughter Irene Juliet Curie and this years winners  Charpentier and Doudna, among the 182 scientists who have received this coveted Nobel prize in Chemistry till date. 

The word ‘Madam’ used in the caption of my article in a way is quite significant for this years Chemistry Nobel prize. It reveals the very nature of the works for which the two Madam scientists - Emmanuelle Charpentier and Jennifer Doudna, have received the Nobel Prize in Chemistry and will share the prize money of 10 Million Sweedish Krones. They have been awarded the prestigious Nobel Prize Prize in Chemistry for this year, in recognition of their scientific research, which has led to the development of a technological tool that can be used for editing the very book of life - Genome editing. Their discovery, known as CRISPR-Cas9, helps researchers to make specific and precise modifications to the DNA contained in living cells. The term CRISPR is an acronym for Clustered Regularly Interspersed Short Palindromic Repeat. Palindromic represents a word or a sentence, which reads the same both backward and forward. Take for example the word ‘Madam’, used specifically in the title of the article. It reads the same when read both ways ; forward and backwards. The two Nobel ‘Madam’ laureates have harvested the fundamental scientific understanding  of this naturally occurring palindromic biochemistry phenomenon -  a region of DNA in which the sequence of nucleotides is identical with an inverted sequence in the complementary strand (GAATTC is a palindrome of CTTAAG), to develop their CRISPR - CAS9 technique. The CRISPR/Cas9 is a gene-editing tool that can be used to remove, add, or change a portion of the DNA sequence of a target gene of interest. It is based on a quintessential “cut-and-paste” mechanism, which we routinely use in our document editing, in which the enzyme Cas9 is guided toward a specific DNA region with the help of a small guide RNA molecule. This path breaking technique and use of the guide RNA has opened up a revolutionary way forward for harvesting immeasurable applications of this technology, which are destined to present themselves in the form of therapeutic medicines for genetic disorders like the sickle cells, haemophilia etc. 

According to a recent report (5th October 2020), Genome Editing Market by Application (Cell Line Engineering, Animal Genetic Engineering, Plant Genetic Engineering), the market valuation of this CRISPR - CAS 9 and other similar technologies, is estimated to be valued at around 10 Billion US Dollars by 2026. It is also estimated that there will be an increase in government support for the biotech and pharmaceutical companies in the better treatment of genetic diseases using this technique. Industry captains are certain that this technology will lead to a paradigm shift in investments in the field of genetic engineering and that its impact will be felt across biomedical research, clinical medicine, agriculture and wider society, besides its potential to treat or prevent human diseases particularly the genetic disorders. The current Covid 19 pandemic will accentuate the governmental support and investment in such technologies. India in a way is a leading global manufacturer of vaccines. It is one of the major countries which the global community is looking towards for mass manufacturing of vaccines and such other pharmaceutical products that can reach a vast population. Therefore it is earnestly hoped that the benefits of this technology, which have already began to play out in the international market, will accrue to the Indian pharmaceutical companies and to the global human society.

However, it must also be noted with circumspection that this technology also brings with it major ethical concerns and critics have cried foul and are afraid that this technology may prove to be a Frankenstein monster that may lead to creating gene edited babies and such other unethical practices and end up interfering into the very act of ‘God’. It is worth recalling the claim made by the Chinese scientist - He Jiankui, of illegally altering the genetic make up of twin girls which was reported in late 2018. This information shook the world and called the attention of the global community on the ethical concerns that such technology comes with. Fortunately, He Jiankui was found guilty of illegal practices in trying to alter the genetic makeup of twin girls and was jailed for three years. The alertness of the global community in combating such unethical and illegal practices give hope that this technology will not go unchecked nor will it be abused. Scientific community and human society is now aware that the Chinese scientist by engineering mutations into human embryos, which he used to produce babies, was capriciously nosediving into an era in which science could rewrite the gene pool of future generations by altering the human germ line. The Chinese scientist had also flouted established norms for safety and human protections along the way. Although there was no definitive evidence that the Chinese scientist actually succeeded in modifying the girls’ genes — or those of a third child expected to be born later, the experiments had attracted so much attention that the incident has created an alarm for the human society and may very well alter scientific research for years to come. This incident has also divided the society in their opinion on scientific research in the field of genome editing.

But then the ethical concerns of scientific research have not been new to the human society. Ever since the Nobel prize winning discovery of the structure of DNA in 1953, by James Watson and Francis Crick, who were awarded the Nobel Prize in 1962, which was followed the successful sequencing of the entire Human Genome fifty years later in 2003, there have been debates in favour and against such scientific research and ethical concerns have been voiced by the society. Interestingly, it is in anticipation of such ethical concerns that the Human Genome Project (HGP) has specifically had earmarked a portion of the HGP budget (3%) which was meant to address the ELSI - Ethical, Legal and Social Issues, associated with the sequencing of the human genome. Hopefully there will be requisite funding, legislation and laws which will be framed by countries to ally the fears that the CRISPR technology may create. 

While speaking of the benefits and concerns debate, which crops up during such scientific research, particularly in the context of this years Nobel winning works in Chemistry - the CRISPR technology tools, I am reminded of two quotes from history one relatively recent and the other from the eighteenth century, which reveal the two sides of the divide that are natural to such debates, which span centuries. Jonathan Swift in his famed ‘The King of Brobdingnag, “Gulliver’s Travels”, wrote in 1727 ; ‘Whoever could make two ears of corn, or two blades of grass grow upon a spot of ground where only one grew before would more essential service to his country, than the whole race of politicians put together”.  Perhaps his statement can be appreciated in the Indian context where the benefits of scientific research were applied in agricultural practices by scientists like Normal Borlaug and M S Swaminathan, who heralded the green revolution in India and helped us in combating hunger and famine quite effectively. However, there is another side to any scientific research and that relates to the concerns that come with some of the scientific research, which can be seen from the statement of Prince Charles, made in 1998. He said “ I believe that we have now reached a moral and ethical watershed beyond which we venture in to realms that belong to God, and to God alone. Apart from certain medical applications, what actual right do we have to experiment, Frankenstein like, with the very stuff of life?” 

As exemplified in the above quotes, throughout history, there have been those who have embraced change, which emanates from scientific research and those who have expressed concern and have preferred to clung to old ways, feeling known risks are better than unknown benefits. So we should not be surprised that history may be  replayed as we come to grips with this new technology, which is a result of the wonderful research work of the two Nobel Madams who have been awarded this years Chemistry Nobel Prize. 

May Science triumph and may humanity triumph as well.


Unknown said…
Very Informative and useful blog for Teaching community
Aiworehabs said…
Patients that recover from covid tend to have side effects that are negative from the virus, they include complications that can be resolved with rehabilitation measures by rehabilitation medicine center.

Popular posts from this blog

Tribute to Dr. Vikram Sarabhai : The Father of Indian Space Program

  Tribute to     Dr. Vikram Sarabhai : The Father of Indian Space Program Images - courtesy Nehru Science Centre, Mumbai. Every year 12th of August is celebrated as International Youth Day, which for India is quite special for it also happens to be the birth anniversary of one of the visionary scientists of India - Dr Vikram Sarabhai, the father of Space programmes in India and the scientist who established the Indian Space Research Organisation - ISRO, an acronym, which has now become a household name in India. While wishing everyone, particularly the youths, a very happy International Youth Day, I wish to take this opportunity to recall a tribute, which I had paid to one of India’s greatest of Sons - Dr Vikram Sarabhai, who has made profound contributions for India. Dr Sarabhai, while     establishing ISRO charted out a special path, which was almost impossible to dream of. What is even more special is that he founded the famous Physical Research Lab - PRL, in 1947 when he was a yout

Sangolli Rayanna : Forgotten Freedom Fighter

Remembering Sangolli Rayanna : Forgotten Freedom Fighter, who shares his birth and death destiny with India. 15th August and 26th January, our independence day and the Republic day respectively, are inextricably linked to every fellow Indians. These two dates, which are connected with the destiny of our revered nation, are inextricably linked with one of the heroes of India - Krantiveera Sangolli Rayanna, a forgotten hero who made his supreme sacrifice fighting the British. Krantiveera is a Kannada word used to describe Sangolli Rayanna, an army chief of the Kittur Kingdom that was then ruled by Kittura Rani Channamma. On the occasion of our Independence day, 15th August, which also happens to be the birthday of Rayanna, I had paid my reverence to him by posting a Facebook post and now on the occasion of the seventieth year of our Republic Day, 26th January, which incidentally also happens to be the day when Rayanna, made his supreme sacrifice and was hanged by the Britis

Super Pink Moon - 27th April, 2021 : A Celestial Spectacle, a Repeat from Last Year.

  Super Pink Moon - 27th April, 2021 : A Celestial Spectacle, a Repeat from Last Year. The second wave of the Covid 19 pandemic has once again impacted our science centre, which is now closed for the visitors. Last year too we had faced a similar situation in April 2020. But then taking advantage of our stay in the office quarters, we had organised a live Facebook telecast of the Super Pink Moon, which occurred last year on 7th April 2020. One year has passed but unfortunately the Covid situation continues to be quite grim with rapidly increasing numbers adding more than 300,000 numbers each day for the past couple of days. Our Centre is once again closed to the public and we now have another occurrence of the Super Pink Moon, which will appear tomorrow 27th April, 2021. We plan to go live on our Facebook page to telecast the Super Pink moon tomorrow. Therefore four of us - Jhuma, Sheetal,    Rajesh and I tried the test run this evening and I took a couple of photographs from my new Sa

Sainik School Bijapur: Nostalgic memories of yesteryears.

Sainik School Bijapur: Nostalgic memories of yesteryears . I am blessed to be among those very few privileged alumni from one of the prestigious chain of residential schools in the country - the Sainik School Bijapur. Very recently I joined the    ‘All India Sainik School Alumni Association (AISSAA)’ group, which has motivated me to write this post to introduce the Sainik Schools in general and the Sainik School Bijapur (SSBJ) in particular with special emphasis to our batch (1970-77) to other members of the AISSAA and to all others, through this blogpost. The Sainik School scheme was launched by the government of India (Ministry of Defence) in 1961 to bridge the gap that existed in the rank of the military officers from    certain sections of the Indian society.    The scheme was conceived by V. K. Krishna Menon, the then Defence Minister of India, with an aim to rectify the imbalance caused by religion, class, and creed among the Officer

Eulogy for our School Buddy and a Jewel of our batch, Admiral Srikant, AVSM, DG, Project Sea Bird (Karwar Naval Base)

Eulogy for our School Buddy and a Jewel of our batch, Admiral Srikant, AVSM, DG, Project Sea Bird (Karwar Naval Base) Just three months ago, 16 th September, 2020, during the foundation day of the Sainik School Bijapur (SSBJ), Vice Admiral Srikant was invited by the Principal and management of SSBJ to be the Chief Guest and to deliver the 57 th Foundation Day lecture at our school, which he did so admirably. Srikant in his outstandingly motivational address to the young Ajeets, highlighted the significance of education in one’s life and he emphasised the role that Sainik School Plays in shaping the lives of the students and that he is one of those lucky ones to have been an alumnus of this great school. His speech was full of motivation to the young cadets who listened to him with rapt attention and looked up to him as their role model. It was such a great honour and privilege for all of us - the Ajeets of 1970 to 1977 batch, that our very own buddy classmate – Srikant, was invited t

Science Museum Metro Station - A Immemorial Visit.

  Science Museum Metro Station - A Immemorial Visit. One endearing image of the city of Mumbai, these days, is an unprecedented level of infrastructure construction work going on across the city including the works for the Mumbai Metro. Notwithstanding the Covid pandemic, which has rampaged the city of Mumbai and brought down the pace of these works, the Mumbai Metro construction work has once again picked up pace and continuing unabated. One of the major construction site of the Mumbai Metro is right opposite our science centre where a Science Museum station is coming up in    the Metro-3 corridor. The Mumbai Metro Line 3 is one of the most challenging engineering works for the Metro construction in Mumbai since this corridor is fully underground and it connects south Mumbai to the city’s western suburbs. It therefore was a privilege and honour for me to visit the Science Museum metro construction site yesterday and see first hand the tunnel boring machine live in action. The Line 3 m

Kargil Vijay Diwas : Nation owes its debt to Colonel MB Ravindranath - our fellow Ajeet-, the Indian Army (all forces included) and specially to those who made the supreme sacrifice in service of our nation.

Two Decades of Kargil Vijay Diwas : Salutations to the Battle heroes who made supreme sacrifice (My blog posted on 26th July 2019) This day, 26th July, 20 years ago, will ever be etched in the annals of the bravery of the Indian Armed forces, and befittingly the entire nation joined in  commemorating this momentous occasion in the form of विजय दिवस, which, this year,  was celebrated all across the nation with the theme, ‘Remember, Rejoice and Renew’. The valour of our armed forces in this treacherous war, thrust on us by the enemy in deceit, can best be exemplified by its comparison with the ‘Charge of the Light Brigade’, by Alfred, Lord Tennyson, who, in his famous poem, portrays  the bravery of the 600 men of the Light Brigade, who marched into the jaws of death, into the mouth of hell, without asking the reason why, but firmly believing in the orders to do and die in service of the nation. True to the traditions of the Indian Armed forces, more than 500 (527 to be

Lt. Col. Ajit Bhandarkar (25 RR) : श्रधांजलि to the brave शौर्य चक्र Soldier.

Shaurya Chakra, Lt Col. Ajit Bhandarkar -  श्रधांजलि to the martyrdom of the brave Soldier. AJIT BHANDARKAR’s Wife and two Sons (both in defence services) during their visit to the Sainik School Bijapur for the opening of the Ajit Dwar. This day last year - 30th October, 2019, was the twentieth year of the martyrdom of our dear friend Lt Col. Ajit Bhandarkar, who made the supreme sacrifice in service of his motherland on this very date in 1999. Colonel Anirudh Gudi, another classmate of ours (1970-77), from the batch of Ajit Bhandarkar, at the Sainik School Bijapur, posted his tribute to our dear friend Ajit in our Ajeet 77 group with some very nostalgic and memorable photographs of our dear friend Ajit and his family. I have therefore updated the tribute which I had posted last year in my blog. Here it is for all my dear friends who have been gracious to follow my blog. Lt. Col. Ajit Bhandarkar (25 RR) : श्रधांजलि to the brave शौर्य चक्र Soldier (My Blog post posted

Basava Jayanti: Birth Anniversary of Jagat Guru Basaveshwara

Basava Jayanti: Birth Anniversary of Guru Basaveshwara.  Bssava Jayanti’, an auspicious day when Lord Basaveshwara was born, is celebrated on Vaishaka Shudda Tritiya, Rohini Nakshatra and this year it is celebrated on 14th May, 2021. This year marks the 890th birth anniversary of Lord Basaveshwara (also referred to as Basavanna), 12th century leading social reformer, thinker, poet, philosopher and a saint, who was born in 1131 AD in a small village in Ingaleshwar,  near Bagewadi (now Basavana Bagewadi) in Bijapur District in Karnataka. He is known for the establishment of a Parliament type edifice - the Anubhava Mantapa, besides being revered as a saint by the Veerashiva (Lingayat) sect, a dominant community in Karnataka, which Basavanna established to create an egalitarian society in the true spirit of humanity. Almost 900 years ago, he imagined a society of equals, which could mirror modern day democratic traditions. An idea, which is so difficult to imagine b

In remembrance of Prof R Balasubramaniam (Bala) : A Decennial Tribute to a beloved friend.

In remembrance of Prof R Balasubramaniam (Bala) : A Decennial Tribute to a beloved friend. A decade ago, on Wednesday, the 9th of December 2009, in the wee hours (2.20 AM) of that fateful early morning, the uncertainty of life played out its role from the hands of the sutradhar of human destiny, resulting in the almighty taking into her fold - the heavenly abode - one of the finest of scientists, academician and an extraordinary archeo-metallurgist - Professor R Balasubramaniam. Around 9 AM in the morning of that fateful day - 9th December, 2009 - I received a forwarded email from Prof Sharada Srinivasan, which she had received from Prof Bikramjit Basu, then Associate Professor and P K Kelkar Research Fellow at the Metallurgical department at IIT Kanpur, confirming the inevitable passing away of our beloved Bala, who had been ailing for quite some time suffering from jaw cancer. He was constantly suffering from breathlessness for more than a